EcoStrategy Group’s new report, Trends in Sustainability Reporting: A Close-Up Look at Bay Area Companies, provides a helpful overview of the business value for reporting on environmental sustainability and a solid checklist of issues to take into consideration if you are about to embark on a sustainability report.
The study analyzes how the top Bay Area companies report on their sustainability efforts and rates their performance based on 14 specific attributes including: materiality, stakeholder relevance, target setting/tracking and completeness.
The report begins by exploring the question, “Why Companies Report?” I find two of the answers most compelling: to respond to increasing volume of inquiries and to manage reputation and brand image.
It includes an assessment of what elements make a sustainability report stand out.
What makes a good sustainability report?
The report includes a description of the essential ingredients of a successful sustainability communications strategy and provides examples of companies that are doing it well. As a professional who helps companies craft sustainability reports, I was interested to see what components the report found most important.
Here are five attributes that make a sustainability report great and some questions to explore if you are just getting started:
1. Materiality: What issues are most significant? What issues are your competitors reporting on? Bay Area companies that did a stellar job on the issue of materiality, according to the report, include Adobe, Applied Materials and Autodesk. Adobe for example, organizes its CSR strategy and report around six key issues: employee engagement, community involvement, corporate governance, environmental sustainability, product use and innovation and supply chain and procurement. Its environmental sustainability program focuses on office buildings, waste management and product packaging. It is clear which issues they have prioritized.
2. Stakeholder inclusiveness: Do you have a process for engaging your stakeholders? Do you understand your stakeholders’ perspectives? Cisco and HP were among the top rated companies for this attribute.
3. Target setting and tracking: Have you clearly established measurable reduction targets? Do you have a system in place to track and report progress? Are you tracking greenhouse gas emissions? Apple and Clorox were among the companies ranked high for this factor.
4. Completeness: The authors define a “complete” report as one that considered impacts in the supply chain, in the distribution channel and in use by the end customer. Seems like the issue of social responsibility and working conditions in the supply chain deserved to be called out here.
5. Ease of use: How many clicks does it take to find your sustainability report online? Can it be easily read without printing it out? This final attribute comes from me and my experience with CSR reports.
Adobe wins some extra points, in my book, with its easy to navigate web site and three-page summary. I got lost inside Autodesk’s 105 page report that took several minutes to find from the home page. Applied Materials was the only web site I visited (I only looked at about six of the winners) that had a clear, easy link on its home page to its citizenship report.
And the winner is…
The report includes a table of the top-rated companies by size segment and calls out Cisco, HP and Intel as the overall top rated companies.
$1 to $2 Billion
- National Semiconductor
$2 to $5 Billion
$5 to $10 Billion
- Applied Materials
- $10+ Billion
If you want a full copy of the report, you need to e-mail firstname.lastname@example.org.
If you are not reporting, tell us why
The report include a list of large Bay Area companies who are not investing resources in sustainability reporting. It would be interesting for those of you not reporting to share here your thoughts on why.
Ed Note: The most rigorous standard for sustainability reporting is GRI. 3p is pleased to be offering a certificate course in GRI sustainability reporting this summer in the San Francisco Bay Area. Please click here to get more information.
Deborah Fleischer is president of Green Impact, a strategic environmental consulting practice that helps companies walk the green talk. Green Impact designs campaigns to engage employees and develops sustainability communications that bring successes to life. You can follow her occasional tweet @GreenImpact.